In what could be one of the most surreal political soundbites of the year, former President Donald J. Trump reportedly floated the idea of deporting tech mogul Elon Musk during a private strategy session with advisors. The remark, allegedly made in jest but laced with Trump’s trademark populist flair, has stirred a firestorm of speculation, memes, and high-level legal commentary.
“Maybe we should send him back. He thinks he’s bigger than America,” Trump is said to have quipped, according to a source who attended the meeting at Mar-a-Lago.
It was the kind of statement that perfectly straddles the Trumpian line between the absurd and the politically calculated. While impossible in a legal sense—Musk is a naturalized U.S. citizen—the suggestion hints at something deeper: the ongoing tension between populist politics and elite technocracy.
A Billionaire on the Brink?
Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla, SpaceX, and owner of social media platform X, has long positioned himself as a renegade innovator—an outsider genius disrupting old systems. But under Trump’s lens, Musk has increasingly come to symbolize what Trump calls “the globalist elite”—untouchable billionaires shaping policy without public consent.
In recent months, Musk has taken positions that angered many conservatives, including support for expansive AI governance, floating the idea of a universal basic income, and refusing to endorse Trump’s 2024 campaign. Though Musk has also opposed many progressive policies and publicly clashed with the Biden administration, his libertarian leanings do not neatly align with Trump’s agenda.
The flashpoint, insiders say, came after Musk met with foreign diplomats to promote a proposed international AI council—without any coordination with U.S. officials. That, according to Trump’s inner circle, was interpreted as “borderline treasonous” behavior by the former president.
“Trump views loyalty as everything,” says Dr. Lila Newton, political scientist at Georgetown University. “When someone like Musk operates globally, but doesn’t bow politically, it triggers his instinct to isolate or punish.”
Legal Reality Check
Despite the bombast, legal scholars were quick to shut the door on any literal interpretation of Trump’s comment. “A naturalized citizen cannot simply be deported unless they obtained citizenship by fraud, and even then, it’s rare and requires due process,” explains immigration attorney Samuel Rizwan. “There’s no law that lets you deport someone just because they’re annoying or powerful.”
Musk became a U.S. citizen in 2002 after emigrating from South Africa via Canada. Since then, he has built some of America’s most successful enterprises and helped reshape the private aerospace industry. In the eyes of many, he embodies the American Dream.
Still, the political damage may already be done. Trump’s base thrives on perceived defiance, and Musk’s growing influence—particularly over X, a platform many conservatives now see as a free-speech refuge—makes him a complicated ally. The joke, or threat, depending on one’s view, resonates because it plays into anxieties about who really holds power in America: elected officials or the billionaire technocrats.
Musk Responds—Sort Of
True to form, Musk responded cryptically on X, posting a meme of a rocket labeled “ME” launching from Earth with the caption, “Escape velocity achieved.” The post racked up 20 million views within hours.
Later, in a brief interview with a Swedish tech podcast, Musk dismissed the controversy. “I’m not going anywhere,” he said, laughing. “Unless Mars is taking immigrants now.”
Behind the humor, some observers detect a real strategic concern. Musk is known for working with multiple governments and may feel pressure to minimize political friction, particularly with U.S. regulators overseeing Tesla and SpaceX. Recent reports indicate SpaceX is bidding on a massive defense contract—something that would be threatened by prolonged political entanglement.
Trump’s True Intent?
Political analysts suggest Trump’s comment was less about Musk himself and more about reasserting dominance over a narrative slipping away from him. In the post-Twitter world, Musk’s X has become a digital megaphone with no clear ideological allegiance. That ambiguity may be exactly what frustrates Trump.
“Trump wants loyalty, not neutrality,” says Alex Vargo, a campaign strategist who worked on Trump’s 2020 effort. “When someone that powerful stays in the middle, he treats it as disloyal.”
By publicly questioning Musk’s place in America—even as a joke—Trump may be sending a message to other elite figures: pick a side or get targeted.
Tech, Power, and 2024
As Trump continues his campaign to reclaim the presidency in 2024, expect more confrontations with figures like Musk. The populist vs. technocrat dynamic will likely intensify, especially as AI, data privacy, and globalism dominate headlines.
This episode, strange as it is, encapsulates a central tension of the modern era: how democratic societies deal with unelected titans who wield more influence than entire governments. Whether through playful trolling or serious power plays, the clash between Trump and Musk is far from over.
In the meantime, Musk remains firmly planted on U.S. soil—though one can’t help but imagine him programming an escape capsule, just in case.